Ever looked at your brand and thought, it looks the part, so why doesn’t it feel like me?
If that’s you, you’re in good company. After working with hundreds of business owners, I’ve noticed that nearly all of them tell me the same story. They built the brand in the wrong order. Not because they’re careless, but because nobody told them there was an order.
That’s why I put together Branding 3×3, a simple framework designed for clear, effective founder branding. In this post, I’ll share where the framework came from, the main mistake I notice in almost every founder brand identity, the common hiccups that go with it, and a quick way to check if your own brand needs a tweak.
Key Takeaways
- Branding 3×3 started as a presentation and became a book because founders kept coming back to it.
- The one thing I see in almost every founder brand: the identity was built before the foundations.
- The logo rarely travels alone. Expecting branding to fix the business, speaking to everyone and borrowing values and language tend to come with it.
- A logo can’t carry meaning your purpose, values and positioning haven’t given it yet.
- Going below the waterline first means working in order: Foundations, Audience, Identity.
- You can check whether you started in the wrong place in an afternoon, then fix it one step at a time.
Contents
- Where Branding 3×3 Came From
- The One Thing I See in Almost Every Founder Brand
- The Other Mistakes I See Along the Way
- Why Starting Below the Waterline Changes Everything
- How to Tell If You Started in the Wrong Place
- What to Do Next, Whatever Stage You’re At
Where Branding 3×3 Came From
It didn’t start as a book. It started as a presentation.
It Started as a Presentation
I put it together to help business owners get a handle on the three core pillars of branding, along with the three simple parts inside each one. That was really all there was to it-just a helpful way to explain things. But founders kept bringing it up. They’d mention it in our catch-ups, share it with their teams, and use it to make decisions months down the line.
That made something really clear to me: people weren’t looking for another fill-in-the-blanks template. They wanted the clear thinking behind how brands are actually built.
Why It Needed to Be a Book
A presentation gives you a nice snapshot, but it doesn’t leave much room to sit down and work through things. People wanted to go through the steps at their own speed, with handy worksheets, real stories, and a warm cup of tea nearby. So I turned it into a full book. This second edition dives even deeper into building real connection, because the way people pick and stick with brands has shifted. Today, connection isn’t just a nice bonus. It’s everything.
What’s Inside
Three main pillars, nine straightforward parts, and one easy framework. Each chapter wraps up with a quick action step so you can put things into practice as you go instead of just reading along. You’ll also find extra guides on running a brand check-up, catching brand drift early, keeping your confidence up when life gets busy, and creating practical guidelines you’ll actually use day to day.
The One Thing I See in Almost Every Founder Brand
They started with the logo.
The Logo Came First
And that’s totally understandable. A logo feels like a big step forward. It’s visual, exciting, and usually the first thing everyone asks to see. So the brand gets a name, a set of colours, and a shiny new mark, and then the business tries to stretch itself to fit inside.
I know how that goes firsthand. Early in my career, I spent a lot of time helping other brands look great on the surface. It took me a bit longer than I’d like to admit to realise that looking great and having real depth are two very different things.
What It Looks Like From the Inside
You might recognise the signs: a website that looks lovely but doesn’t quite explain what you do, blog posts or social updates that just aren’t clicking with people, or a brand that feels a bit like you’re wearing someone else’s coat. Customers might even ask lots of basic questions because it’s tricky to tell how you can help them.
There’s nothing wrong with the artwork itself. It just needs a strong foundation sitting underneath it.
A Logo Can’t Carry What You Haven’t Decided
A logo is a quick visual shortcut that stands in for something much bigger. But if you haven’t figured out your main purpose, your core values, or where you fit in the market, there isn’t much for that shortcut to represent. It ends up being just a nice shape that doesn’t say very much.
Caroline Jane Andrew, who kindly wrote the foreword for the book, mentions making those same missteps early on, like jumping straight to logos before clarifying her purpose. She’s definitely not alone in that; she’s just refreshingly open about it!
Your Face Is Part of the Brand
If you run a founder-led business, there’s another layer. People trust people more than they trust companies. They’re not just buying a service. They’re buying into you, your thinking and the way you work. So the brand has to feel like an extension of you. If someone who knows you would look at it and think, no, that’s not her, there’s a gap worth closing.
Why It’s So Easy to Do
Visual style sits right above the surface where everyone can see it, so naturally, it’s what people talk about most. Purpose, values, and positioning sit quietly underneath. Since they aren’t as visible, they often get skipped over. But skipping them means building on soft ground. You end up with a brand that looks active on the outside, but feels a little hollow on the inside.
The Other Mistakes I See Along the Way
Starting with the logo is the most common hiccup, but it rarely happens on its own. Here are a few other common patterns that tend to pop up alongside it.
Expecting the Brand to Fix the Business
It’s easy to put too much on branding. A fresh logo, slick visuals, and a nice tagline won’t fix core business challenges on their own. Branding isn’t a quick fix. It’s a megaphone. If your offering, customer care, or pricing aren’t quite aligned yet, a lovely design just makes those gaps look prettier. It helps to get those core pieces sorted first, then build a brand that truly reflects them.
Trying to Speak to Everyone
When you try to appeal to everyone, your message gets a bit watered down. It loses its distinct personality and starts sounding like everyone else in your field. Focusing on who you’re really for isn’t about pushing people away. It’s just about being clear. When the right people hear you, they’ll feel like you’re speaking directly to them.
Choosing Values That Sound Good
Words like trust, honesty, and reliability are wonderful, but they’re really just the basics every business should have. Since everyone aims for them, they don’t make you stand out. Often, your most authentic values come from the things you stand against or refuse to compromise on. And if a value isn’t visible in how you run things day to day, it’s more of a nice wish than an active value.
Borrowing Someone Else’s Language
It’s very easy to pick up phrases that seem to work well for others. A competitor’s catchphrase finds its way onto your site, then into your proposals, and soon everything starts sounding similar. Your brand voice works best when it comes directly from what you believe, shared in your own genuine words.
Saying Yes to the Wrong Clients
Most of us have been there. Maybe the project budget was great, or it was a quiet month. But then comes the miscommunication, constant scope changes, and that familiar heavy feeling when a new email pops up. That bumpiness is actually really helpful feedback. It’s showing you where your boundaries are and who your brand is truly meant to serve.
Notice how none of these are pure design problems? That’s the key takeaway. Almost all of them live right below the surface.
Why Starting Below the Waterline Changes Everything
It helps to picture your brand like an iceberg. Above the water: your logo, website, social pages, and visual presentation. Below the water: your core purpose, values, positioning, and a real understanding of your audience and their journey. That hidden part is your foundation and your roadmap.
The Order Matters
Branding 3×3 has three pillars, with three elements in each. Foundations: purpose, values and positioning. Audience: your ideal customer, their journey and connection. Identity: logo and design, visual style, and messaging and story.
That order is deliberate. Foundations first. People second. Look and voice last.
A Brand That Got It Right
Look at Monzo – they didn’t just set up another traditional bank; they took a clear stance. Banking should be straightforward, friendly, and easy to understand. They chose plain English over confusing terms and open updates over secrecy. Their positioning came straight from what they genuinely believed, which is why people connected with them so quickly and knew right away if it was for them.
Identity Should Embody, Not Decorate
When your foundation is clear, designing your identity becomes much more rewarding. A relationship coach once reached out to me wanting some “sparkle” in her brand through a metallic colour. But as we talked, it became clear that the sparkle was her own warmth and energy. The identity needed to capture her personality, not just add a glossy finish. When I shared the concepts, she was moved to tears because it felt so true to her.
That only happens when the work starts below the waterline. Design that decorates is nice. Design that embodies is unmistakably you.
What Changes When You Work This Way
Writing content feels much more natural. Everyday decisions become simpler. Choices around design stop feeling like guesswork, because you can simply ask if something fits your purpose instead of relying on personal taste. And best of all, the right clients start finding you because your brand message has real heart behind it.
How to Tell If You Started in the Wrong Place
You don’t need a workshop to find out. Try these four checks.
Step 1: Cover the Logo
Take a look at your homepage and cover up the logo with your hand. Would a visitor still recognise your voice and style? If it feels generic, your visual branding, and likely your core message, could use a bit more personality.
Step 2: Say Your Why Out Loud
Can you state your brand purpose in one sentence without wincing? Not a slogan. A reason you exist beyond making money. If you can’t, that’s your starting point.
Step 3: Describe Your Customer Without Demographics
Skip age, location and job title. What do they believe? What keeps them awake at night? If you’re guessing, you’ve found the gap.
Step 4: Look at Your Last Ten Clients
Do they match the person you built the brand for? If not, the brand is attracting the wrong people, or you never got clear on the right ones.
What Your Answers Tell You
If you found a few gaps, please don’t worry at all! It’s not a mistake; it’s just helpful insight. It simply highlights where to focus your energy next, which is much better than putting out content and wondering why it’s not connecting.
What to Do Next, Whatever Stage You’re At
If You’re Just Starting
Start as you mean to go on. Work through your foundations before you brief a designer. It’ll save you money, and a rebrand later.
If You’ve Been Going a While
Your business has probably changed more than your brand has. Revisit your purpose, values and positioning, then check that everything above the waterline still matches.
If You’re Growing and Scaling
Your services have expanded, your client base has matured, and your goals are bigger. But your brand might still be reflecting where you started rather than where you are today. That’s a very common thing called brand drift, and a Brand Audit is a quick, practical way to see what needs aligning.
If Budget Is Tight
Nobody should go into debt for branding. Choose a font and a colour you like and use them consistently. Skip the AI-generated logo, because you’ll never own it. You’ll get bored of your look long before your customers do, so stick with it.
Be Patient With It
Building recognition takes a little time. People often need a few touchpoints to recognise your brand, several to remember it, and many more to feel complete trust. That’s why steady consistency matters so much. Showing up with the same heart and look every time builds genuine confidence over time.
Final Thoughts
I put Branding 3×3 together because I wanted every founder to have the clear guide I wish I’d had starting out. A great brand isn’t just a logo and a colour palette. It’s a clear purpose, a set of genuine values, your space in the market, the people you serve, and finally, a welcoming look and voice. Get that order right, and everything falls into place naturally.
If any of this sounded familiar, give yourself a break! Almost everyone starts with the logo. What matters is taking a pause to build those steady foundations underneath. Clarity brings so much confidence, and it’s always a great time to lean into it.
If you’d like a friendly second opinion on your brand, a Brand Audit is a wonderful place to start. It helps you see what’s working well, what could use a tweak, and where to begin. Feel free to pop an email over to clare@webrewyourbrand.com and we can chat through it together!
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I have to work through Branding 3×3 in order?
It really helps! Starting with Foundations, moving to Audience, and finishing with Identity keeps everything grounded. Jumping straight to visuals is usually why brands can end up looking great on the outside but feeling a bit incomplete underneath.
Is Branding 3×3 only for new businesses?
Not at all! It’s just as helpful for established businesses as it is for brand-new ones. You can return to these steps whenever your business evolves or grows.
What are the most common branding mistakes?
Designing a logo before setting your foundations is the big one. Other common ones include expecting branding to fix underlying business offers, trying to speak to everybody, picking generic values that aren’t put into practice, and taking on clients who aren’t quite the right fit.
Do I need a logo before I start?
No. You need clarity first. If you already have a logo, check it against your foundations rather than starting again. It may need nothing more than a few tweaks.
How do I know if my foundations are strong enough?
Can you state your purpose in one sentence? Do your values show up in how you actually work? Does your positioning feel distinct from your competitors? Three honest yeses mean you’re in good shape. Anything less tells you where to begin.
What if I’ve already built my identity?
Not at all! You can simply revisit your core foundations now, then gently align your current visuals to match. It’s just about fine-tuning what you have so everything feels harmonious.
Where should I start if I’d like help?
Start with a Brand Audit. It gives you a clear picture of where your brand is now and a prioritised plan for what to do next. From there, you can decide whether you need a fresh start or a refresh.


